Once you find the perfect silicone baking mat for your needs, you can stop buying single-use liners and cooking sprays entirely. While all silicone baking mats are made with the same material, there’s a lot of variation within quality and use.
The AmazonBasics silicone baking mat is the retailer's number-one seller in the category, with over 12,500 rave ratings. Baking can be messy, but when you roll out your dough on this Uber durable and completely nonstick-coated silicone baking mat, it’s easy to control.
This mat refuses to stick to even the stickiest of dough and is heat-resistant up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit. Although the mat is more expensive than others, it’s made in France and recommended by bakers, with reviews claiming that even caramel won’t stick.
Though many silicone baking mats claim to be dishwasher safe, this high-quality option leads with this feature. Verified customers on Amazon boast about this mat’s non-stick surface that makes cleanup so easy, you might not need to put it in the dishwasher at all.
Silent is the original French baking sheet that has facilitated the production of many a pastry over the last few decades. Though this mat can withstand heats of up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit, dishwasher use is not suggested.
The Certainty grill mat is essentially a 16-by-70 inch heavy-duty swatch of silicone, designed for maximum customization while cooking. You can cut the roll to fit larger grills or ovens, and the material is sturdy enough to use for anything from cookies to steaks.
These bright and colorful silicone baking mats from Kitchen + Home are not just fun to look at, they also have clean white lines and a modern layout to guide cookie portions and measurements along the edges. They’re BPA-free, and won’t peel, crack or melt even when put to the test in the oven, microwave, or top rack of the dishwasher.
What’s more, no matter how many ingredients you use on them, they won’t absorb odors or flavors, according to reviewers. But it can also give meat, fish, and other dishes crisp and crunchy edges, sans grease (the extra fat drips down from the food).
And because this FDA-grade mat is uniquely designed, artists also use it for drying clay, resin, and other crafts. It’s specifically designed for toaster ovens, sized 8-by-11 inches, which makes it great for single servings, small batches of cookies, or reheating leftovers.
This silicone mat is fiber-glass-coated and BPA-free, which helps food cook evenly and without harsh chemical smells. The kit also includes a recipe book and a Decimal Pen for dispensing batter, which can be used with six different caps for decorating other desserts, too.
This extra large mat is 25-by-18 inches, making it the perfect surface for rolling out sizeable pizzas. You’ll have plenty of room for kneading the dough, so you don’t have to wipe flour off every corner and crevice of your countertop.
To help you find the best silicone baking mats available today, we purchased 15 different options and spent over 10 hours baking and preparing food on them. Securing our testing, we measured each mat on its ability to prevent sticking and how easy it was to clean, whether by hand or in the dishwasher.
We also took into account the overall durability of the mats on our list, and only included those that could last through thousands of baking sessions. Even non-stick surfaces can struggle with sticky dough, but our Velasco mats didn’t experience any sticking at all, which was an impressive feat.
Made of high quality food grade silicone, these mats can hold their own, even in the stickiest situations, which means no more worries about aluminum foil, cooking sprays, or using parchment paper every time you’re baking. We didn’t experience any difficulty unrolling them or rolling them back up for storage.
The mats are plain in design, without any measurement markings, but they get the job done with ease. WHY WE LIKE IT: Amazon combines affordability with durability and usability in the AmazonBasics version of silicone baking mats.
These mats can withstand high temperatures and are super easy to clean up. We tested the mats with cookies, pastries and other baked treats without any problem at all.
They are made specifically for baking macaroni with their piping patterns, and they even include rulers on the sides of the mats for increased usability. The 0.75 mm thickness of the mats makes for really even heat distribution, which is helpful not just for macaroni but for other baked goods, too.
Since they can be cooked at temperatures as high as 500 degrees, these mats are perfect for use with prime rib, oven roasts and more. You’re going to be paying a bit more upfront, but that purchase includes 4 baking mats, a brush and a spatula.
It was nice to get baking mats in different sizes, so we could use them for larger or smaller batches. WHY WE LIKE IT: The Silent is the original silicone baking mat, backed by years of brand reliability and quality.
It can be baked at high temperatures or placed in the freezer, and it’s even stained resistant to last even longer. Since that time, the way Slats are made hasn’t changed a bit, which is an impressive feat.
The Slats are made of food-grade silicone and reinforced with fiberglass mesh, and are hard to stain or damage in any way. WHY WE LIKE IT: The Folksy Super Kitchen silicone baking mat is large and comes printed with helpful measurements to enhance your baking experience.
One of the first things you’ll notice about the Folksy Super Kitchen silicone baking mat is how large it is. This larger size gives you more room to work with, and the included measurement patterns only serve to enhance your baking experience.
These features combined make this the best silicone baking mat for pastries and other things like pizza dough. This added thickness lends itself to an extended lifespan and the ability to withstand more rigorous baking preparation, including cutting dough with metal cookie cutters.
The mat is dishwasher safe, though, so if you can get it to fit in your appliance, it won’t be damaged by the washing process. Our favorite feature here is the printed measurements on the bottom and side of the mats.
This wasn’t too big of a deal in the end, though, since cleaning by hand was still incredibly easy. You’re initially going to spend more on a baking mat than a box of parchment paper, so you’ll want to be sure you get the full value out of your purchase.
We only included options on our list that could withstand the test of time through both calm and intense baking sessions. And while they are rare, we rated mats higher if they could stand up to metal utensils.
When it comes to ease of use, we gave more credit to the mats that could be used in an instant without the hassle of trying to get them to stay flat on your baking sheet. We also gave mats extra points if they included additional features like measurement markings that make sure your cookies are all the same size.
We also considered the overall value of each silicone baking mat, and favored those that provided more value for similar price points. Of course, we compared these additional features to cost to ensure we weren’t unfairly giving more credit to certain products just because they included more mats in a single purchase.
You should buy a mat that will also withstand rolling up and storing, as well as scraping with various cooking utensils. First, you should always purchase a mat that’s easy to unroll and place on your baking sheet, as well as roll up and store.
But many baking mats also include additional usability features like measurements markings or sizing templates for specific food items like macaroni. If these are important to you, be sure to purchase a baking mat that provides similar usability features.
Twist the silicone, and if you see white, there are too many filler products, which can flake off and cause the mat to wear out too fast. Today, they are becoming a common piece of cookware at home.
There are several advantages to using siliconebakingsheets over regular metal baking sheets. Saving money and causing your kitchen to be a little greener.
They will also stand in nicely at times when you would normally use aluminum foil liners. They are made to fit into rimmed baking sheets or to place on flat cookie sheets, and they can withstand temperatures of up to 480 °F but also be taken straight from the freezer to the oven.
Another advantage over siliconebakingsheets over metal baking sheets is that they can be used in the microwave! Since nothing sticks to silicone baking mats, they are very easy to clean.
If you are baking something that is messy, with a lot of sugar or butter, for instance, you’ll love them. You need at least two cookie sheets for that, and if you are baking a huge batch with two ovens, for example, you’d need up to four.
With siliconebakingsheets, you only need one or two metal baking trays (depending on the number of ovens you have going). Several silicone mats can be used to line one or two cookie sheets.
Silicone baking mats have the same advantage that parchment paper can give you. There tends to be less browning on the bottom of baked goods and less potential for burning.
Silicone mats are especially good for baking fish on, as you won’t have to worry about the fish sticking and tearing when you lift it off the mat. As well, if you are using any sort of sticky glaze, you’ll appreciate the non-stick surface of the mat.
A regular silicone baking mat can be used to knead dough on. It’s great for kneading pizza, bread, or even pie dough.
Professional bakers use silicone mats for working with fondant, chocolate, sugars, and other sticky things. Keep in mind that, with the explosion of such products on the market, the quality may be uneven.
Some materials, for example, may be too thin and flexible to use effectively for a large baking vessel. Although, for the most part, you should never need to grease, oil, or flour a silicone baking mat, there are times when it is advisable to spray them with nonstick cooking spray, such as when you are making a very sticky candy.
For example, when baking sheets of fall dough that you wish to keep flat, you can place one silicone mat on top to keep them from puffing up unevenly. However, I find that they take up too much room and I personally do not like using the dishwasher unless it is quite full and not just of a few large items.