Health-conscious cooks use baking sheets to roast everything from asparagus to zucchini and make one -sheet meals for easy weeknight dinners. You’ll need to think about the material, the rim, and whether you want a nonstick surface, among other considerations and features.
If you want to yield impressive results no matter what’s on the menu, keep reading to learn more about the different types of baking sheet sets that are available. Baking sheets are made from a variety of different metals, each of which has advantages and disadvantages.
Stainless steel conducts heat poorly compared to other metals. Anodizing is a process that increases the thickness of the metal’s surface layer by electrochemical means.
Carbon steel sheets usually have a protective coating of oil or wax and can develop a seasoning similar to cast iron. Most have a carbon steel base that’s been hot-dip coated with an alloy of aluminum and silicon.
Once you’ve decided which type of metal baking sheets are best for your cooking, it’s time to consider the features that will make your food taste fantastic. Instead, look for thick sheets with rolled rims that will help keep your pan’s edges aligned.
Wire reinforcement in the rims can prevent your pan from twisting and bending under high heat, which often leads to permanent warping. Baking sheets with elevated, strengthened handles can make it easier for young bakers or those with diminished hand strength to grip through oven mitts.
These flat sheets make it easy to slide soft cookies onto a cooling rack without crushing them. They also promote better air circulation, meaning your cookies will brown and bake more quickly.
Many bakingsheetshave surface treatments intended to improve cooking or prevent sticking and corrosion. Carbon steel baking sheets often have a thin layer of oil or wax to prevent sticking.
This layer thickens with use over time, similar to the seasoning on a cast iron pan. Their slick surface tends to produce flatter cookies with textured bottoms.
Nonstick pans usually cannot be used for broiling because the high heat may damage the finish. If you choose a nonstick baking sheet set, check the manufacturer’s instructions to be clear on washing and temperature restrictions.
Insulated baking sheets feature internal air pockets that help with heat distribution, but they may increase your cooking time. Multi-sheet baking sheet sets designed to nest are easier to store than other types.
Sets in this price range are usually made from stainless steel or aluminum and are not likely to have texturing. They may be constructed of several metals, but they should have some type of lip reinforcement to help resist warping.
If you’re using aluminum foil as a baking sheet liner instead of parchment, keep an eye on your cookies. Foil makes cookies bake faster and causes browner, crispier bottoms.
Never place baking sheets with wooden, plastic, or silicone handle inserts in the broiler. Check the manufacturer’s recommendations, and when in doubt, use parchment paper lining.
Because it’s thinner and sitting on hot metal bars, the sheet’s bottom will expand more quickly than the raised edges and lip. Sheets that repeatedly twist or buckle may crack over time.
Half- sheets can be used to bake cookies, roast vegetables, heat frozen French fries, and handle almost anything else in your kitchen. With baked goods where ornate detail is key, like bunt cakes, consider silicone.
While baking sheets can be used to bake things like cookies, which have a somewhat thick and solid dough, they can be used for plenty of other foods as well, which might not share the same properties. To summarize, the raised edges on baking sheets provide flexibility.
By flexibility, we mean that you’re not quite as limited on the potential uses as you would be with a cookie sheet. A side benefit of having raised edges is that your sheet is more durable.
The raised edges help the sheet to resist warping by providing a rigid structure. Although it might not seem like much, those raised edges on a baking sheet take up valuable real estate, which means you don’t have as much room as you should for your cookies.
Another benefit of not having raised edges is that you’re able to easily slide your cookies off the sheet when they’re done baking. The idea is to hold the sheet by the raised edge, tip it at a slight angle, then slide your cookies onto a plate (assuming they aren’t stuck to the pan…).
They’re made of the same materials and provide the same basic benefits to the foods being baked. Either type of sheet will work for most applications, so don’t stress about it too much.
If you can only afford to buy one, go with a baking sheet, as it provides more flexibility. First, they are known in the baking community for making high quality, commercial grade pans.
The fluted surface not only provided better air circulation, but also contributes to the strength and durability of the pan, which is resistant to warping. This non-stick finish is PTFE, FOA, and BPA free, so you can rest assured that your food is safe.
The non-stick coating provides an excellent food release for your cookies and makes cleanup extremely easy. The material and raised edges help make this baking sheet resistant to warping as well.
These baking sheets from Circular feature the TOTAL Food Release System, which is a combination of a surface with raised circles and a non-stick coating, which is FOA free. The raised circles and nonstick surface allow your food to easily slide off and make cleaning the baking sheet a breeze.
The Chicago Metallic 41800 eighth-size pan is perfect for small batches of baked goods, chicken, and other foods that need to be heated in the oven. Constructed of 16-gauge aluminum, the Chicago Metallic 41800 eighth-size pan resists bending, scratching, and corrosion.
To see if this still applied to today's ovens, they made two identical batches of cookies: one on their favorite cookie sheet, from Tolerate (its shorter sides boast a slightly raised lip to facilitate handling, but it has no true rims), and the other on their favorite rimmed baking pan, from Lincoln Food service, which features a 1-inch rim on all sides. How evenly the cookies baked wasn't an issue; both batches came out perfectly pale golden.
The discrepancy makes sense: Heat rises from the element at the bottom of the oven and circulates in currents to warm the entire chamber. A rimmed baking sheet's raised edges block the hot-air currents, diverting them from the cookies to the top of the oven.
Bottom line: No need to rush out and buy a rimless sheet the next time you bake cookies. America's Test Kitchen suggests checking on cookies a minute or two before the timer goes off, just to play it safe.
Highly Recommended: $21.79 Wear-Ever Half Size Heavy Duty Sheet Pan (13 gauge) by Tolerate (formerly Lincoln Food service), model 5314. “Perfect” cookies, oven fries, and jellyroll in this “flawless” pan.
“Sturdy” pan produced crisp, evenly cooked fries, released jelly roll easily, and was steady with hot pan full of barbecued pork and drippings. Michael's has a large selection of baking supplies and kitchen tools as well as decorations and dessert packaging to help with your next delicious sweets DIY.
Silica is widely used in making glass and is commonly found in beach sand and other natural occurrences like sandstone, with synthetic additives it becomes silicone in a variety of different forms which can then be used for different products. From breast implants (very safe) through to parts of the satellites we send into space (very tough), silicone is an incredibly versatile material.
Because it won’t taint your food with plastic tastes and isn’t toxic, silicone became a kitchen success story almost overnight with designers swooning at the possibilities. Since then, we’ve seen an explosion of fuchsia pink and daffodil yellow spatulas plus some totally fabulous cake pan designs.
Even if you are very careful to my mind it’s an accident waiting to happen, if you pick something out of boiling water and it slips back in with a splash? In addition to sharing up-to-date buying guides, product reviews, and how-to articles, we look to share healthy food recipes as well as tips for cleaning and maintenance, gift ideas, and many other useful ideas to decorate your kitchen with minimum effort and price.